Front office searches, tight budgets and high player prices could slow MLB offseason moves, while several proposed trades appear unlikely.
MLB’s offseason may start slowly
The Angels’ biggest offseason decision may be how long they wait before making any others. Mark P said the news about Mozeliak had only become official a few days earlier, and the club appeared to be at the beginning of its search. Hiring a general manager could take weeks; that person would presumably help choose a manager, who might not be in place by the December 1 lockout. Mark P therefore expects major roster moves could wait until the lockout ends, making a major Angels signing this winter unlikely. The chat opened during a one-day World Series pause, with the queue set to open at 7:43.
That budget caution also shapes the outlook for Cleveland. Mark P put Seiya Suzuki’s likely floor at a $20 million average annual value and three guaranteed years, with four years more likely. Cleveland badly needs a strong bat, but that price is far outside the club’s usual range, so he doubts the Guardians will seriously pursue Suzuki. He also considers Jo Adell a non-tender candidate: his projected $9.6 million salary is steep for Cleveland, despite a 107 wRC+ in 204 plate appearances after his trade. Mark P suspects the Guardians are trying to trade Adell so another team can make the tender decision.
Colorado could afford a free-agent splash, since it has little money committed, but affordability doesn’t make the club attractive to players with other options. Mark P doubts a top free agent would join a team years from contention unless the Rockies overpaid, and sees little reason for the team to spend heavily before it’s ready to win.
Trade ideas meet the price of talent
A proposed swap of Gunnar Henderson for Paul Skenes would at least force both front offices into a serious discussion, Mark P said. It would be an entertaining deal, but he ultimately expects Pittsburgh to turn it down.
Other proposed trades drew quicker refusals. The A’s would want more than Austin Wells, Elmer Rodriguez and Hunter Dietz for Shea Langeliers, whom Mark P sees as a catcher with All-Star potential. Boston’s Franklin Arias, meanwhile, is effectively untouchable: with Arias positioned to replace Trevor Story, Mark P finds it hard to imagine the Red Sox trading him for a slugger. And Michael Massey wouldn’t move the needle enough for the Dodgers in a deal involving Teoscar Hernández and Alex Freeman; if Hernández is moved, Mark P thinks a pitching return is likelier.
Tyler Stephenson shouldn’t command the five-year, $75 million offer suggested by a reader. Mark P estimated two or three years at about $10 million annually. For Houston, a trade of Imai for another short-term bad contract such as Jurickson Profar is possible, but the Astros may prefer to give Imai another chance as a starter or try him in a longer bullpen role. Profar’s situation remains hard to predict.
The Rangers could consider non-tendering Burger and using the money to pursue Nathaniel Lowe. Mark P had already floated non-tendering Burger in his Rangers offseason outlook, arguing that Davis Foscue could reproduce most or all of Burger’s offensive output. His first response to the question, naturally, was that anyone served a “non-tender burger” at a restaurant should send it back.
Payroll plans and roster priorities
The next collective bargaining agreement is more likely to bring steeper penalties and other deterrents for big spenders than a salary cap, Mark P said. The players’ union has been consistently firm in rejecting a cap, which makes that outcome his expectation.
St. Louis, despite exceeding expectations in the first year of its rebuild and having a deep farm system plus a top-12 pick next June, probably won’t trade a group of prospects for an All-Star bat or arm. Mark P doubts Chaim Bloom sees the Cardinals as ready to reload for a pennant run. Oliver Marmol also appears safe: he signed an extension last spring, and Bloom seems to trust him to guide the team through the rebuild. Mark P admitted he was a little surprised Marmol stayed on, but doesn’t expect him to be fired. He added that Adell may now be at a career stage where he moves relatively often.
Detroit has room to improve at first base, right field and designated hitter, potentially by moving on from Spencer Torkelson or Kerry Carpenter. Mark P thinks the Tigers can add enough offense to contend in an improving division, and flagged Suzuki as a particularly strong fit if ownership will spend. Detroit has shown more appetite for large contracts than Cleveland.
The Giants’ needs are extensive: at least one starting outfielder, two starting pitchers and two dependable relievers. They badly need pitching, and Mark P thinks the urgency should persuade ownership to bend its usual resistance to longer-term pitching contracts for a front-of-the-rotation arm. The free-agent class isn’t especially exciting, but it does include starters and relievers who could help. As for Willy Adames, a release is out of the question with five years and $140 million remaining on his contract.
Texas could also look for ways to improve beyond the Burger question; for San Francisco, pitching remains the clearest priority. Mark P put Ha-Seong Kim’s likely deal at two guaranteed years and roughly $8.5 million in average annual value.
For the Red Sox, unloading Masataka Yoshida would likely require absorbing almost all of the $18 million he is owed for 2027. Mark P said Yoshida might not get a guaranteed deal if he were a free agent this winter, or might receive only about $3 million for one year. A release therefore seems more likely than a trade.
What the playoff run could mean for Milwaukee
Milwaukee’s postseason run is bringing in extra revenue, and that could affect the club’s decision on William Contreras. Mark P wasn’t sure the added money would lead to an extension, but thought the Brewers might keep Contreras through 2027 for another championship run and accept the possibility he leaves in free agency afterward. Under the next CBA, Milwaukee might still receive compensation. He expects the team to wait for the World Series and the labor agreement to play out before deciding.
The reader argued that Milwaukee’s reputation for trading stars applies more to pitchers than position players, pointing to the team’s decision to keep Adames, and thought the Brewers had a better chance of re-signing Contreras than many assume. A deep playoff run, plus the prospect of Christian Yelich nearing the end of his contract, could make that possibility more appealing. Mark P’s answer was cautious: the revenue helps, but it doesn’t settle the question.
Nor would a Brewers title necessarily prompt Yelich or Brandon Woodruff to retire. Yelich has two years left on his contract. Woodruff, when it looked last summer as if he might need surgery, had said he intended to return in 2027; Mark P doubts winning a ring would change that plan.
On the chat’s World Series poll, 361 of 441 voters—81.8 percent—picked the Brewers to finish the job. Eighty voters, or 18.1 percent, backed a Rays comeback.
Owners, spending and the shape of a rebuild
Mark P believes Minnesota owner Tom Pohlad has shown he’s serious about winning and spending more aggressively by Twins standards. He said fans had become so disillusioned that Pohlad could see a turnaround in the on-field product was needed, while investments from minority owners erased much of the team’s debt and made a higher payroll more feasible. Mark P has no current reason to doubt Pohlad’s stated intentions, though he said the test is how much owners will invest—and how wisely they spend it.
That distinction matters across the league. Owners may want to win, but a team’s ability to build a contender depends on the money committed and the quality of those decisions. The Twins’ signals are encouraging to Mark P; whether they become sustained spending is still to be seen.
One reader asked whether the World Series result could make Milwaukee more likely to sign Contreras; another wondered whether Chaim Bloom might package prospects for an impact player. Mark P’s answers point to the same restraint: a playoff boost can change the financial calculation, but it doesn’t automatically mean a team is ready to accelerate its plan.
The fragment ends with a reader asking whether the Angels will make the playoffs within the next decade.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.